Should Algorithms Choose for Us?

Before you write your final position, you must earn it — argue both sides first.

The Question

Write the debate motion in your own words in one precise sentence — not the article's words, yours.

The Case For

List three strong arguments in favour of algorithmic recommendation. Use evidence from the article where possible.

The Case Against

List three strong arguments against. At least one must go beyond what the article says — use your own reasoning.

The Harder Side

Mark on the spectrum where your instinct sits — then name the single strongest point on the side you find harder to defend, and explain in one sentence why it genuinely challenges you.

Algorithms should choose

Humans should choose

Your Verdict

Write your position in 80–100 words in your notebook. State which argument from step 3 or step 4 surprised you most — and whether it changed your spectrum mark from step 4.

Why that word?

Discuss Before you write, tell your partner: which single argument across both sides do you think a judge would find most compelling — and why?

Technology01