Does Good Service Need Rules?

The reef functions without a rulebook — now apply that idea to a system you know.

State the question

Write the debate in one fair sentence: should a service system run on designed rules, or on the self-interest of its participants?

The case FOR rules

Write three arguments for designed, explicit service rules — the strongest ones you can imagine, even if you disagree.

The case AGAINST

Write three arguments against rules — for a reef-style system where self-interest, channelled right, creates collective care.

The hardest point to argue

Look at steps 2 and 3. Find the single strongest point on the side you do NOT instinctively favour — write it out in full, then mark your honest lean on the spectrum below.

Rules always

Self-interest always

Your verdict

Name ONE word that captures what both sides are really arguing about — then explain in two sentences why that word, and which side surprised you most.

Why that word?

Discuss Tell your partner which step changed your thinking and why.

Science01